
From Regulation to a Clearer Road: Making Scotland’s Mental Health Code of Practice a Rights-Based Destination
Scotland’s proposed updates on restraint and seclusion bring stronger human rights language, better participation principles and a clearer focus on least-restrictive practice. That matters and the Code is a welcome step forward. But a good map is only useful if it shows where we are going. SCLD believes the Code needs a much clearer route towards preventing, progressively reducing and, wherever possible, eliminating restrictive practices.
Participation needs more than an invite
Being “involved” is more than being asked for a view after the important decisions have already been taken. A human rights based approach requires communication support, reasonable adjustments and independent advocacy so people with learning disabilities express their will and preferences, exercise legal capacity and take a meaningful part in those decisions. Supported decision-making should be an explicit duty, not an optional extra. We are talking of a human rights model under which people with disabilities are recognised as rights holders entitled to rights on an equal basis with others.
For children, ‘last resort’ must really mean last resort
Restraint and seclusion involving children should be exceptional, used only to prevent imminent harm, kept as short as possible and backed by enhanced safeguards. The revised Code should contain an explicit presumption against their use. Childhood should never come with a reduced set of rights or ‘adult’ standards.
Accountability needs to be genuine
Strong internal governance is welcome, but external accountability is needed. Health Boards should not be left to mark their own homework. Independent monitoring, accessible complaints and effective remedies are essential. Each Board should publish a restraint-reduction plan, report annually on progress and release disaggregated data so patterns, including disproportionate use by age or disability can be seen and addressed.
SCLD’s message is simple: keep the progress but make clear the destination – raise the bar. The revised Code should make prevention and reduction explicit goals, strengthen supported decision-making, require reasonable adjustments and advocacy, create enhanced protections for children, and put independent oversight and transparent reporting at the heart of accountability. This should not be limited to the Code but the destination of mental health reform. Scotland now has an opportunity to move from managing restrictive or coercive practices to provide services that need them less and, wherever possible, not at all.
Full Version
Audio version

