Housing and the Right to Independent Living

Iain GillonSCLD Publication

The historic policy of institutionalisation kept many people with learning disabilities on the margins of society.  It isolated them from family and denied them everyday opportunities to participate in community life.  In many cases, they were left vulnerable to neglect and abuse. 

Thankfully, the last 25 years have seen huge change: most people with learning disabilities now live in the community, in their own homes or with family. Young people today expect – quite rightly – to live full, active lives in their chosen communities. That progress should be celebrated. 

But significant challenges remain. 

People with learning disabilities still face major barriers to suitable housing and support. A shortage of accessible homes, inconsistent housing advice, and funding pressures mean many cannot access the variety of housing options they need.  

And an additional barrier is the belief that people need “specialist accommodation” with lots of extra and expensive features. In reality, there is good reason to believe that when people have the right support this type of accommodation is often unnecessary. 

Despite this some people with learning disabilities are still forced to live far away from their families because there isn’t suitable housing and support where they live. Others are stuck in hospital even though they are clinically ready to leave.  

In fact, the latest figures show that 157 people with learning disabilities in Scotland are living in hospital. Nearly half of them are ready for discharge, but they remain detained. Shockingly, almost a quarter have been there for more than ten years. 

This is about more than housing and support – it’s about rights.  

The United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD) makes clear that everyone has the right to live independently and be included in the community. No one should have a living arrangement forced upon them. People must have genuine choice over where they live, who they live with, and the support they receive. 

Safe, secure, accessible and affordable housing is a precondition for independent living. For some, this may mean a social housing tenancy; for others, supported accommodation, adaptations to a mainstream home, or light-touch support a few hours a week. Some people may need more intensive help with daily living.  

What matters most is choice. Access to housing advice and advocacy for people with learning disabilities can facilitate a housing options approach that considers tenure choice, personal circumstances, support and accessibility requirements.  When housing and support reflect a person’s needs and preferences, it enables them not just to live in a community, but to be part of it. 

Design is important too. Considerations such as space for carers, adaptable layouts, accessibility, proximity to services, and good transport links can be critical to enabling people with learning disabilities to lead the life they want.  And Housing Support can provide the glue that enables people to manage daily living, maintain social networks and develop life skills.  

Without appropriate housing, support and services, people with learning disabilities are at risk of institutional living and a loss of personal choice and autonomy.  They may be physically present in the community yet remain excluded from it.  

Independent living isn’t a privilege – it’s a right. 

For people with learning disabilities to fully realise this right, there needs to be investment in community-based housing and support, more accessible and adaptable homes, and genuine choice and control for people over where and how they live.  By doing this, Scotland can help to empower everyone to be included, valued, and equal citizens.